Two months into the school year, buses are still dropping children off at school late. Some buses are serving three schools.

At a Citywide Council for District 75 busing committee meeting on Nov. 10, the Office of Pupil Transportation (OPT) tried to explain why this is happening.

❝

That is our largest issue: we don’t have enough bus drivers, and because we don’t have enough bus drivers, we can’t service all the students.”

LaQuanna Chambers, OPT’s Executive Director of Communications and Engagement

When Lighthouse asked whether the driver shortage was the problem, LaQuanna Chambers, OPT’s Executive Director of Communications and Engagement, said: “So that is our largest issue: we don’t have enough bus drivers, and because we don’t have enough bus drivers, we can’t service all the students.”

The city needs “at minimum at least 300 more bus drivers,” she said.

OPT didn’t say why the drivers are gone. In September, Lighthouse reported that three federal immigration actions in seven months pushed drivers out of the industry, according to Logan Bus Co. executive Corey Muirhead.

More kids, fewer drivers

The driver shortage coincides with increased demand. According to OPT:

  • Curb-to-school riders (mostly students with IEPs) rose from 61,000 last year to 67,700 this year.

  • About 6,000 students have IEPs that limit how long they can ride.

  • Students in temporary housing are up 98% over three years, which changes routes.

OPT says it puts kids from several schools on one bus when it’s short on drivers. Sara Catalinotto of Parents to Improve School Transportation (PIST NYC) said mixed routes were “a policy choice of 2011,” and that since then “the cost of this busing has shot up, and these mixed routes lead to a lot of confusion.”

❝

I can understand being five or 10 minutes late, but not 55 minutes late every single day.

Perturbed mother

Chambers said OPT prefers routes to one school and will go back to them “once we’re out of this shortage.”

One mother said her daughter has arrived late every day since school started. “I can understand being five or 10 minutes late, but not 55 minutes late every single day,” she said.

Chambers didn’t offer an easy answer. “I don’t think that there would be any answer that I can say right now that would honestly satisfy parents, right?”

One mother read from an OPT reply to one of her tickets. It said the driver “can move forward with the route one minute after the pickup time if the student isn’t outside for service.”

“When I call the bus company to ask for a bus time or a pickup time for my son, the only thing that they can tell me is that my son is the 16th pickup, but that doesn’t help me try and figure out when I should bring him downstairs,” she said.

“He gets picked up at a different time every single day, so I don’t know how they expect me to just be downstairs and just waiting for them to show up. So I have to wait for them about 20, 30 minutes, but they can’t wait more than a minute or two for me to come downstairs.”

Last week, she said, “the driver said he was downstairs, I said I was coming, and it doesn’t even take me two minutes to get downstairs, and he left.”

❝

I have to wait for the bus about 20, 30 minutes, but they can’t wait more than a minute or two for me to come downstairs.

Perturbed mother

Chambers confirmed the rule. “One minute is the time that bus drivers are required to wait, but they should provide you with a pickup time so that you are not outside for 30 minutes.”

What the city says it’s doing

  • Hiring: OPT is working with bus companies on signing bonuses and other ways to recruit and keep drivers.

  • Contracts: The bus contracts date to the 1970s. “Our contracts are very old,” Chambers said. A state law keeps the city from writing new ones with the job protections drivers want, so the old ones keep getting amended. Lupe Hernandez of the Public Advocate’s office pointed to a bill, sponsored by Sen. Robert Jackson and Assembly Member Carmen De La Rosa that would allow those protections in new contracts. “We didn’t have cell phones when these contracts were drafted,” she said.

  • Tracking: A pilot has drivers scan students on and off the bus with a QR code.

  • Omni cards: Next school year, the paper card will be replaced with a sturdier one.

What you can do now

  • File a ticket every time, in Support Hub or by calling OPT customer service. OPT says it tracks bus companies by complaint trends. Save every ticket number. Parents report that they’ve filed dozens of tickets.

  • Know the one-minute rule. Drivers are only required to wait one minute. If they don’t give you a pickup time, file a ticket.

  • Track the bus with the NYC Schools Bus app. You’ll need an NYC Schools Account. Ask your parent coordinator or bus coordinator for non-public schools if you don’t have one.

  • Ask about rideshare or an Omni card if your child’s mandated busing isn’t running.

  • Fill out CCD75’s bus support form, so the council has its own record of D75 problems.

  • Testify. City Council holds an oversight hearing on school busing Wednesday, Nov. 18, at 1 p.m., with a rally on the City Hall steps at noon. You can register to testify by Zoom.

Keep Reading